Have your say & ask the experts

BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

Last post Oct 24, 2009, 9:54 PM by PJPro. (9 replies)
Sort Posts:

Posted on Oct 21, 2009, 12:54 PM

BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

Hi - I have a Humax Freesat box and with this I can get BBC HD. I have the Humax connected to my surround system, so can receive 5.1 sound (when available). My question is, how do I find out which HD programmes are transmitted with 5.1 sound - without switching the surround system on all the time?? Is there any way of telling on the Humax EPG, or is their a TV guide online? I can not find the detail on the BBC's own HD website either!  Can anyone advise?

Posted on Oct 21, 2009, 1:03 PM

321174

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

On the Humax Freesat box, the Programme Information i-plate should indicate whether or not Dolby Digital is being transmitted.

Posted on Oct 21, 2009, 1:06 PM

321182

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

Although of course DD doesn't always mean 5.1...
Consulting Editor, What Hi-Fi? Sound and Vision / whathifi.com
Audio Editor, Gramophone

Posted on Oct 21, 2009, 1:09 PM

321185

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

That's right - it tells me if DD, but not if in 5.1.

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 10:46 AM

321174

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

Dont go off the info on the i bar, this will only tell you that the sound is being transmited in Dolby Digital. However it will not display the info 5.1 or 2.1, If your home cinema amp is conected and set up right. The amp will automaticaly decode 5.1 when transmitted.


Tip. Leave your amp in Dolby Pro-Logic II setting this will give you 5.1 sound all the time. And when the BBC HD transmit in Dolby Digital 5.1 your amp will decode this sound and return to Dolby pro- Logic II when the BBC return to Stereo or 2.1.

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 9:08 PM

322978

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

Perhaps I've got mine set up wrong then. I watched Star Wars tonoght on ITV HD and expected to get 5.1. I didn't and had to use Dolby PL II.

Was Star Wars transmitted in 5.1?
My useful(?) threads can be found here.

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 9:14 PM

323232

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

PJPro:
Perhaps I've got mine set up wrong then. I watched Star Wars tonoght on ITV HD and expected to get 5.1. I didn't and had to use Dolby PL II.

Was Star Wars transmitted in 5.1?
No it wasn't.
Pioneer PDP-LX5090/BDP-LX71,Humax HDR/9300T,AB-IPBox,Mac Mini,Beresford Caiman,Roksan Kandy MKIII,Arcam AV9/P7,PMC FB1i/TB2M-Ci/DB1i,BK Monolith DF,Chord cables,Tacima CS929

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 9:22 PM

323235

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

OK. Thanks. Probably means I'm alright then. Wonder why they didn't bother?
My useful(?) threads can be found here.

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 9:32 PM

323238

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

PJPro:
OK. Thanks. Probably means I'm alright then. Wonder why they didn't bother?

I rarely watch ITV HD because very little of their output appeals,and i like to watch films in entirety and not cut 'n' shut with advert's.But i've yet to come across anything that's had 5.1 audio  when i have watchted ITV HD.

Pioneer PDP-LX5090/BDP-LX71,Humax HDR/9300T,AB-IPBox,Mac Mini,Beresford Caiman,Roksan Kandy MKIII,Arcam AV9/P7,PMC FB1i/TB2M-Ci/DB1i,BK Monolith DF,Chord cables,Tacima CS929

Posted on Oct 24, 2009, 9:54 PM

323244

Re: BBC HD Freesat question on 5.1 sound - please help!

I'm with you on that. I very rarely watch ITV HD and almost never bother switching on my AV amp. I just thought that Star Wars might be worth it....and the sound was better than just using the speakers in my TV. That said, my kuro's speakers aren't too bad for most casual watching.
My useful(?) threads can be found here.